Comments (3) | Reviews (0)
avatar
Sam Cunliffe
27 Feb 2020, 12:17
Hey Marco

This looks cool. I have a soft comment (surprise surprise) it's about the analysis interface / UI.

In my opinion it's also worth mentioning the fact that this is integrated into the basf2 software and available to all users of the collaboration. And also that you can update/calibrate the trainings for different runs/experiments/detector conditions etc (because: database). Not really sure where you put such a sentence, maybe the end of sec. 4? I mean: it was also some effort for you to make this accessible to "normal" nonexpert collaborators.

If you like my suggestion you can probably cite the Belle II core software paper. Maybe there's a database standard ref.

Also: ultra ultra minor by your authors all have superscripts 1,2,3 but there's only one institute.

Sam.
avatar
Marco Milesi
04 Mar 2020, 03:52
Sam Cunliffe wrote on 27 Feb 2020, 12:17:

Hey Marco

This looks cool. I have a soft comment (surprise surprise) it's about the analysis interface / UI.

In my opinion it's also worth mentioning the fact that this is integrated into the basf2 software and available to all users of the collaboration. And also that you can update/calibrate the trainings for different runs/experiments/detector conditions etc (because: database). Not really sure where you put such a sentence, maybe the end of sec. 4? I mean: it was also some effort for you to make this accessible to "normal" nonexpert collaborators.

If you like my suggestion you can probably cite the Belle II core software paper. Maybe there's a database standard ref.

Also: ultra ultra minor by your authors all have superscripts 1,2,3 but there's only one institute.

Sam.

Thank you Sam for the comments.

I have updated a new version that addresses all of them. See in particular the end of Sec. 3.
avatar
Sam Cunliffe
05 Mar 2020, 08:35
Marco Milesi wrote on 04 Mar 2020, 03:52:


Sam Cunliffe wrote on 27 Feb 2020, 12:17:

Hey Marco

This looks cool. I have a soft comment (surprise surprise) it's about the analysis interface / UI.

In my opinion it's also worth mentioning the fact that this is integrated into the basf2 software and available to all users of the collaboration. And also that you can update/calibrate the trainings for different runs/experiments/detector conditions etc (because: database). Not really sure where you put such a sentence, maybe the end of sec. 4? I mean: it was also some effort for you to make this accessible to "normal" nonexpert collaborators.

If you like my suggestion you can probably cite the Belle II core software paper. Maybe there's a database standard ref.

Also: ultra ultra minor by your authors all have superscripts 1,2,3 but there's only one institute.

Sam.

Thank you Sam for the comments.

I have updated a new version that addresses all of them. See in particular the end of Sec. 3.


Thanks! We really need a "like" button in this docserver system.



[ No further comments, reads very well ]

 Subscribe to this discussion. You will then receive all new comments by email.

Add comment


Once logged in, authorized users can also attach files.
Note: you have not defined your nickname.
N/A will be displayed as the author of this comment.